Fog to Pyre: The impact of Supreme Court Judgment Complexity on Dowry Deaths
We use Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques to examine if judgments’ complexity in Supreme Court cases influences dowry deaths in India. Leveraging the quasi-random assignment of judges to cases, we find that a one-unit increase in the complexity of judgments captured by the Fog Index in a state year increases dowry deaths by 2% in the subsequent period. Based on estimates of the Value of Statistical Life (VSL), this increase in dowry-related homicides of women costs $1.83 million in a state year or 51 million USD for the country annually. In otherwise similar judgments, very high complexity increases the incidence of future dowry deaths by 15%. However, having women justices on the panel of judges in such cases mitigates the effect of higher complexity.
Fog to Pyre: The impact of Supreme Court Judgment Complexity on Dowry Deaths
We use Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques to examine if judgments’ complexity in Supreme Court cases influences dowry deaths in India. Leveraging the quasi-random assignment of judges to cases, we find that a one-unit increase in the complexity of judgments captured by the Fog Index in a state year increases dowry deaths by 2% in the subsequent period. Based on estimates of the Value of Statistical Life (VSL), this increase in dowry-related homicides of women costs $1.83 million in a state year or 51 million USD for the country annually. In otherwise similar judgments, very high complexity increases the incidence of future dowry deaths by 15%. However, having women justices on the panel of judges in such cases mitigates the effect of higher complexity.